Page 1 of 2

Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:20 am
by Lukasaurus
I've had the crossbow since about level 4 or whenever the earliest is that you can pick it up. I am in level 10 and found a better bow than the earlier bow, but the crossbow is still more powerful. The stats are crossbow strength 20, speed 9, and the crookhorn bow is str 19 speed 11. Does speed make a huge difference?

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:54 am
by Gahluisse
A good reason to use the bow would be the fact that you should have way more arrows than quarrels, so you will not run out of projectiles against stronger ennemies. But... well, that's also a good reason to keep both the bow and the crossbow.

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2012 4:11 am
by Cyriel
Crookhorn has higher speed compared to other bows. The tradeoff is 1 attack power for 2 speed rating, resulting in much more damage over a shorter period of time (especially with double fire)

And, as said, there's more arrows than bolts available earlier in :)

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 3:47 pm
by Vermis
I just found this bow as well and I was rather disappointed. Perhaps it's design error? True, there are more arrows early on but I never had a problem with bolts really (the battles early on are over quite fast) and by the time I got my hands on the Crookhorn I had 28 bolts. Enough for every fight I've had so far. In comparison I have 29 arrows.

Also, remember the arrows have attack power 1 and the bolts 2, so in reality the crossbow is 22/9 and the bow 20/11. Both 31 points total. Is the speed really THAT good? I'd accept it if the bow shot magical arrows you didn't have to enchant beforehand, but this seems more and more like an error to me.

Developer opinion?

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 4:06 pm
by Darklord
Vermis wrote: Also, remember the arrows have attack power 1 and the bolts 2, so in reality the crossbow is 22/9 and the bow 20/11. Both 31 points total. Is the speed really THAT good?
Killing an enemy with that one extra shot you get before you die = Priceless! :P

It's a matter of taste, personally I go for slow weapons, dance in and do a massive hit, then dance out again. :)

Daniel.

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:21 pm
by Vermis
Indeed, I just love the Ancient Axe on my minotank. Crazy Rampage hits, 300 in one swing! That said, slightly more speed for a little less damage after 6 levels behind the last Iron Door... meh. It just doesn't make sense! 8-)

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:26 pm
by Darklord
Vermis wrote:Indeed, I just love the Ancient Axe on my minotank. Crazy Rampage hits, 300 in one swing!
Haha, yes me to! I love that Ancient Axe! :D

Only trouble I have is it drains my Mino's stamina like anything! Talk about a one hit wonder! :lol:

Daniel.

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:50 pm
by Poomermon
Crookhorn is a better ranged weapon. It gives you 2 point speed bonus which compared to crossbow is a 22 % increase. Crossbow does +2 more damage (bolts do 2 damage and arrows only 1) but compared to endgame attack power which should be around 50 or something that 2 damage is only about 4 % decrease.

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:08 pm
by Empyrean
Weapon speed is effectively a multiplier. A weapon with 20 speed will attack twice as fast as a weapon with 10 speed. Poomermon's explanation is correct.

Re: Crossbow more powerful than Crookhorn?

Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 2:40 pm
by Vermis
Thanks, both 8-)