Grimrock

3 times:
Normal (Sword Fighter, Dodge Dagger Rogue, Fire & Earth Mage, Air Mage)
Hard Toorum (50 Axes, etc.)
Hard Hardcore (Unarmed Fighter, Dagger Assassin Rogue, Front Row Dodge Archer Rogue, Ice Mage)

It's a good game and I'd like to play it once more, but there's just not enough content to play it again, not on my own at least...

Maybe if someone could come up with a crazy party build - double ice mage, frozen mace etc. or something?

Was close to completing my second playthrough, but then Diablo 3 was released.

1st party.
Human Fighter (Swords, Armor)
Minotaur Fighter (Axes, Armor)
Insectoid Mage (Air Magic, Spellcraft, Staff Defense)
Lizardman Rogue (Missile)

2nd party.
Insectoid Fighter (Armor, Axes)
Insectoid Fighter (Armor, Maces)
Minotaur Rogue (Assassination)
Minotaur Rogue (Missile)

Unfortunately I never got to finish my first game.

Once. I did start a new game but quickly lost steam. Overall a little disappointed. But a great start and great things will come from the editor.

overall i did 2 complete, am on 3 right now

1st... regular party (fighter, 2 rogues, fire/earth mage; terrible build, did not know what i was doing with skills all over the place; 22 hours)
2nd... all rogue party (fun, quick, effective, 11 hours)

3rd... legionaire party (fun but frustrating, progress very slow, lvl 7 now, 10hr)
4th... regular party with son (6years, he chose the party, i move, he solves the puzzles, we're ending lvl 5, 5hr)
5th... torrum (build w/ armors 50 and axe, strange and kinda slow, but wanted something different, lvl 9, 10hr)

Finished 3 times.

First time was on hard with 4 rogues (dagger/fist/2 throwing)

Second time was on easy with 2 fighters, rogue and mage

Third time was toorum


Thought about making another combinations but playing with mages is really bad due to their rune system. Too slow and unintuitive .

I played through it 7 times including the T mode.

Finished once. Might replay it some time, but not anywhere soon.

Only once on hard/oldschool with the stereotype party build. Mino fighter, human fighter, insectoid mage, lizard rogue. Then got T to level 6 and got bored. Will probably finish that playthrough sometime, but as people say it's a scripted single player experience (a very good one at that). The replayability is still very limited.

Would be cool if it was possible to make a random/roguelike mode with this engine though. Oh man.

Anyway. Sequel/community made dungeons will be coming, weehaw!

I've just finished a third playthrough. Two fighters, mage and a rogue. This time with party created by Random Party Generator I've mentioned before viewtopic.php?f=3&t=2559&start=10#p26648. It was really fun and refreshing.

EDIT (and a tiny necro-bump):


Forth party has finally made it. I think I'll wait with fifth party for an editor
It was a mage only party based loosely on the idea presented in this thread: viewtopic.php?f=13&t=2662.

So far, after five full playthroughs, I've led out of Grimrock two fighters, seven mages, seven rogues and one ranger