I'm timing it badly, or my concept how to solve this puzzle is wrong.
Image in spoler (to shorten this post)

Any help?
SpoilerShow

This was exactly what just got me past this puzzle after spending way too much time throwing and trying to time it. Did the above (but I used throwing knives) and did it first try. Thank you!Nikolos wrote:A quick way to do this one (assuming you have a full party) is to equip three separate people with a rock/knife/shuriken. Hit the plate, listen for which opens, and turn and throw at that one. You have to get all three in the same try, or you'll have to start over.