Tile based movement vs free movement style

[Greco]

Which of the two styles you prefer for rpgs/dungeon crawlers?
1) Tile based movement (like DM, EOB, GRIMROCK) or
2) Free movement like ultima underworld, skyrim and most recent rpgs?

Personally, I am a fan of the tile based movement style. I find it easier, more accurate, faster etc. For me it is the best style for rpgs and especially dungeon crawlers! I longed for 20 years to find a game with the style DM and EOB introduced and I finally found it. thank you almost human!

[isamu]

+1 for tile

[Darklord]

I like both.

Generally I'm happy with free movement, but I love classic dungeon crawlers to, so was very happy to go back to such a movement mechanism.

Daniel.

[antti]

I like them both but for different reasons. I think tile based movement is more suitable for puzzles and tactical combat with a party and free movement works better for a more action-adventure style games.

[Kukulcan]

The grid based movement is especially great for touch screen devices, where most free movement style controls are less than perfect.

[Rya.Reisender]

I only like grid based movement. I basically only play games with grid-based movement whether it's a 3D dungeon crawler or a 2D top-down RPG. I just like the gameplay of that style a lot.

[Ixnatifual]

I like both. A game can be built around either and be fun.

[5hassay]

For LoG, I definitely prefer the tile based movement.

I was actually expecting that in addition to turn-based gameplay, but was pleasantly surprised to still get the feel of it; feels like a fast-paced turn-based gameplay, :>.

[Neutronium Dragon]

Like most of the others who've posted, I'd say it really depends on the game.

LoG works well with tile-based movement because, in terms of puzzle elements and combat style, it's designed around that, and I enjoy its gameplay.

Ultima Underworld (as one example), despite sharing many of the puzzle-based elements and evasion-based combat as a dungeon crawler, would NOT work with tile-based movement; free-form mobility is simply too important to the design - and I also enjoy its gameplay.

Neither one would work well if you tried to shoehorn it into the other's style.

[petri]

As a developer I like tiles better because it's so fun and fast to build the levels. As a player I'm with Antti et al.