I think this would be a great thing to evaluate certain suggestion threads and might come in handy in some other situations. I guess the forum code supports it anyway (it's kind of a standard feature), so why not enable it?
Actually you accusing me of using a straw man argument kinda seems like a straw man itself. INCEPTION! To begin with, saying why it should be implemented [by the developers] if modding can do it anyway is a knockout argument, that can be used to choke every single suggestion thread in this forum. By...
Why make suggestions anyway? Just sit on your ass and mod it in if you want it so bad. See what I did there? I doubt Grimrock will be the only dungeon brought to us by AH in the long run (if I remember right, there was some shady announcement in one of the blog posts that they might be working on an...
Well in my opinion I made some pretty good points while you didn't so I guess we won't come to a conclusion about that. You actually made 5 posts in this thread about why it sucks to have this implemented, so if you are not interested in it in any way, why bother telling that over and over again? We...
Why are virtual rewards a bad thing? Usually you play for fun. Rewards are fun, especially the ones you earned the hard way. I don't get the whole "it punishes players who don't find the whole set" thing. Why does it punish you? With this attitude you can also say that hiding items behind ...
I like the idea of set bonuses, simply because it rewards secret hunting and completionist gameplay. I know, that other games used set boni before, but why should that be an argument to not implent them? You may or may not have noticed, that LoG itself is a huge "Ripoff" (don't freak out o...
To be honest, the timed puzzles weren't THAT hard and the most difficult of them were completely optional, so what's the big deal? If you can't get an optional item because you are too slow, so be it. These games are not about anyone beating them without trouble. Especially the optional challenges a...
I also don't get how anyone could run out of food. I was so freaking PACKED with food all the time, that I had to leave half of the stuff on the ground. I didn't pick up any food during the last 2-3 levels and even then I finished the game with three full bags of the more filling stuff like lizard s...